Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!

In this Discussion

Here's a statement of the obvious: The opinions expressed here are those of the participants, not those of the Mutual Fund Observer. We cannot vouch for the accuracy or appropriateness of any of it, though we do encourage civility and good humor.

    Support MFO

  • Donate through PayPal

Money-Losing Retail Crowd Keeps Buying Stocks as Market Teeters

https://finance.yahoo.com/news/money-losing-retail-crowd-keeps-093000952.html

(Bloomberg) -- In a stock market battered by trade turmoil and growing fears of an economic slowdown, retail investors are doubling down, undeterred as their losses mount.

Individual traders pumped more than $12 billion into US equities in the week ending March 19, retail-trading data from JPMorgan Chase & Co. showed. The pace of buying was significantly higher than the group’s 12-month average, according to Emma Wu, a global equity derivatives strategist at the bank.

Market watchers keep a close eye on retail traders as they are often the last to cut their exposure to stocks, so the latest bout of aggressive buying from mom-and-pop investors may suggest that equities haven’t found the bottom yet.

The recent behavior of individual investors is characteristic of a “down” year in the stock market, Wu said. It was also seen in 2022, she noted. That’s when the equity benchmark sank 19%, the only down year of the past six. “This is a hallmark of their ‘buy-the-dip’ mentality,” Wu said.

Comments

  • edited March 21
    @JD_co - You beat me by 3 minutes! I’ll delete my duplicate thread and will endeavor to work faster! :)

    From my deleted thread:

    This appears to contradict another posted article documenting flows out of U.S. stocks. The difference may lie in the type of investor. Perhaps large / institutional investors have been fleeing while small retail investors remain resilient or double-down?

    Personally, I haven’t lost any money this year. Off to one of my better starts. I don’t own much tech or have much exposed to U.S. large cap.
  • ACTIVE DIPPERS !!??
  • edited March 21
    These broad generalizations are, imo, pointless. What kind of stocks are these retailers buying? MAG-7 momentum stocks? What sector? Or are they just plowing $$$ into index funds, which by their very nature, are market-cappy/momentum-based?

    They make it sound like individual investors should just go to cash and sit the market out right now....
  • Thus far, Tech has pulled back after a tremendous run-up. Not much else going on in equities.

    Sentiment has been shifting and now we see how the markets digest a trade war.

    Retail money is supposedly the "stupid" $$$, but Institutions aren't necessarily "smart" money, IMHO.
  • edited March 21
    rforno said:

    These broad generalizations are, imo, pointless. What kind of stocks are these retailers buying? MAG-7 momentum stocks? What sector? Or are they just plowing $$$ into index funds, which by their very nature, are market-cappy/momentum-based? They make it sound like individual investors should just go to cash and sit the market out right now....

    +1

    What I’d like to know is how much of this buying is passive flow into 401-Ks or other retirement accounts? Is there any data on the percentage of so called “retail investors” still working vs the percent who are retired? A guess would be that a much higher percentage are working and dollar averaging in. However, in terms of actual wealth controlled, retirees may well have the upper hand.

    Although I earlier posted the article, it does sound like 90% hype and 10% substance. Shamefully short on details.

    From JD_co - ”Thus far, Tech has pulled back after a tremendous run-up.”

    Yes. We can thank TSLA for a good part of the market damage. It has lost 50% of its value since mid December.


  • yep, sentiment indicator is the marginal discretionary, not the auto-indexer flow.
    however, relative to auto flows, it would be very interesting to suss out retirement plans trading out of their u.s. indexes.
  • They're following the advice of the anodyne analysts: Stick to the plan. Market timing is bad. Politics shmolitics, they're always yapping in DC. No sign of recession here. Temporary volatility. Buy the dip.
  • from @rforno: They make it sound like individual investors should just go to cash and sit the market out right now...

    Yes. The headline is very slanted. How does BB know these retail investors are “losing” money?
    Except for the past 2 months they’ve done very well in the S&P or momentum chasing. Two months is a terribly short period to measure investing success.

    IMHO - The tide is yet to go out …
  • Bloomberg Today

    BTW at bottom of Article they do not mention that Ives said Muskrat should get out of the Government and go back to running the company, as he has caused this crash

    TESLA stock is in a freefall. Its sales are plunging around the world. Even its most avid Wall Street bulls are turning cautious. But one group is buying the electric-vehicle maker’s shares like never before: CEO Elon Musk’s fans.

    The company has long had an ardent fan base of individual investors who hang on Musk’s every word on X, the social-media platform he owns. They analyze Tesla in great detail in online forums and largely function as a hype crew for the stock.

    But their current level of enthusiasm is staggeringly high, even by recent historical standards. Individual investors have been net buyers of Tesla shares for 13 straight sessions through Thursday, pumping $8 billion into the stock, retail trading data from JPMorgan Chase’s global equity derivatives strategist Emma Wu shows. That’s the biggest inflow over any buying streak since 2015, which is as far back as the data goes.


    What makes the buying notable is Tesla’s share price has sunk 17% over this time, wiping out more than $155 billion from its market value.

    “Tesla made some rookie to mid-stage public market investors extremely wealthy, a lot of people became millionaires because of this stock,” said Nicholas Colas, co-founder at DataTrek Research. “People don’t forget that. And they will come back to a stock again and again if they feel it has been beaten up.”


    Tesla shares have been on a steep slide since mid-December when it touched an all-time high fueled by optimism from Donald Trump’s election victory. But that euphoria vanished, with the stock retreating more than 50% from its Dec. 17 record, making it the second-biggest decliner in the S&P 500 Index this year. The rout has been so brutal that on Thursday, Musk sought to reassure Tesla employees during an all-hands meeting.


    What’s become clear is what Wall Street thought would be a boon for the company — Musk’s prominent role in the Trump administration as the head of the Department of Government Efficiency — has instead become an albatross. His growing political presence and involvement with controversies in Europe have triggered a backlash against the company and its leader, with the cars increasingly seen as political symbols. Protesters have thrown Molotov cocktails at Tesla showrooms and vandalized charging stations.

    Sales of the Tesla’s cars have sunk in key European markets, such as France and Germany, as well as in China and Australia. Global numbers won’t be available until the company reports its first-quarter delivery figures early next month, but analysts across Wall Street have been aggressively cutting their estimates for sales and profits, citing the bleak data from around the globe.


    On Thursday, Morgan Stanley analyst and longtime Tesla bull Adam Jonas lowered his price target on the stock and reduced his sales expectations for the company, citing growing competition, an aging vehicle lineup and a “buyers’ strike from negative brand sentiment.” However, he kept his buy-equivalent rating on the shares, saying the weak near-term expectations are “not particularly narrative changing” for a company whose future depends on robotics and artificial intelligence.

    Wedbush analyst Daniel Ives on Friday lauded Musk’s efforts for “hand-holding” employees and investors at a key time, and said that if the CEO continued to lead on his vision, the stock will be on a growth path where 90% of its valuation will be led by autonomous-driving technology and robotics. This bullishness explains at least some of retail traders’ continuing enthusiasm for the shares.

    “These kind of investors don’t care about valuations at all,” Colas said. “They just believe in the future of the company and Elon Musk’s abilities.”
  • edited March 21
    https://www.barrons.com/articles/lutnick-tesla-stock-elon-musk-16a729f4?st=Uqajtr

    Short snippet: ”In an apparent bid to reverse that trend, President Donald Trump publicly praised the car company and committed to buying a vehicle during an event with Musk that saw Tesla cars parked on the White House lawn like at a dealer’s showroom.”
  • You do realize all these Tesla bulls are just pumping Tesla which is probably one of their largest holdings as they don't want to lose anymore. It's all a game. Robotics and self driving... he's been saying that since 2016. It's just a car company that's waaaayyyy over valued.
  • If I buy the Tesla from the White House auto mall do I get free 'my pillows' with it or is it the other way around?
  • You might find some orange makeup and a dusty $60 Bible in the glove compartment. Plus some empty McDonalds wrappers.
  • edited March 21
    @Mark - Yes. They have pillows in place of standard airbags ...:)
  • @Mark Oh, you just have to have the Cybertruck Transformer Version. It transforms into a junk pile as you drive it. It is the ultimate in today's disassembly Transformers.
    The Cybertruck has MAJOR issues
  • edited March 21
    Following are excerpts from a current report by The Associated Press:

    Nothing that a little glue won't fix...
    U.S. safety regulators on Thursday recalled virtually all Cybertrucks on the road, the eighth recall since deliveries to customers began just over a year ago.

    The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration’s recall, which covers more than 46,000 Cybertrucks, warned that an exterior panel that runs along the left and right side of the windshield can detach while driving, creating a dangerous road hazard for other drivers, increasing the risk of a crash.

    The stainless steel strip is bound to the truck’s assembly with a structural adhesive, the NHTSA report said. The remedy uses an adhesive that’s not been found to be vulnerable to “environmental embrittlement,” the NHTSA said, and includes additional reinforcements.

    But other than that, there's just been a couple of minor problems...

    And a few excerpts from a report by "Wired":
    Five of the Cybertruck’s recalls have required Tesla drivers to bring their vehicles into the shop. The most sweeping have included recalls related to failed front windshield wiper motor controllers and malfunctioning pedal pads, which Tesla said were treated with an unapproved soap during assembly that allowed them to become trapped, leading to “unintended acceleration.”

    Even before the Cybertruck began to roll off production lines, the truck was subject to snafus and delays. Its glitzy 2019 unveiling event may be most memorable for an incident in which a prototype’s supposedly unbreakable glass failed to stand up to a metal ball thrown at its driver window. Amidst the pandemic, Tesla pushed Cybertruck production from 2021 to late 2022 and finally to late 2023. Meanwhile, its base price jumped from $40,000 to $61,000.

    Leaked internal documents later obtained by the German newspaper Handelsblatt and WIRED showed that, by January 2022, Tesla was still struggling internally with a preproduction “alpha” version of the vehicle, which had basic issues with suspension, body sealing, noise levels, handling, and braking.

    So there's been a few glitches. What do you want for only $61k (or $99.9k for the high end model)? Give the guy a break- he's been very busy with other important stuff that no voters asked him to do.

    Note: Text emphasis added in the AP report.

  • I’m of an age where « environmental embrittlement » might cause any part of me to fly away. What an expression for « glue failure! »
  • BenWP said:

    I’m of an age where « environmental embrittlement » might cause any part of me to fly away. What an expression for « glue failure! »

    Mostly held together with glue here …:)

  • After taking my bigger than normal chunk from the IRA in January---after a winning 2024--- I'm down just -2% at the moment. Nothing to write home about. Market conditions are dicey. Everything is political, when you come right down to it. No avoiding politics, no matter if you choose to just go and hide. But this retired retail investor is buying stocks only with "free money" from dividends offered from specific stocks. And I'm still re-investing monthlies in my bond funds, plus PRCFX.
Sign In or Register to comment.