Here's a statement of the obvious: The opinions expressed here are those of the participants, not those of the Mutual Fund Observer. We cannot vouch for the accuracy or appropriateness of any of it, though we do encourage civility and good humor.
I'm not very familiar with BINC so I can't comment on fund similarity. It may be worthwhile to consider the following three multisector bond funds.
River Canyon Total Return Bond Fund - Institutional (RCTIX) Intrepid Income Fund - Institutional (ICMUX) CrossingBridge Low Duration High Income Fund - Institutional (CBLDX)
Because drawdowns are a consideration for you, for diversified multisector bond funds I like ESIIX and CUBIX. Although not the same kind of fund as BINC, I like EGRIX, which is a global macro absolute return bond fund. It also has had relatively low drawdowns and has had good returns.
@Observant1, why did you sell River Canyon Total Return Bond Fund RCTIC?
I was looking at Vanguard Multi-Sector Income Bond VMSAX. It looks nice a nice fund, but it had a fairly big drawdown in April (about the same as PIMIX).
@Observant1, why did you sell River Canyon Total Return Bond Fund RCTIC?
Not Observant, but I also used to own RCTIX. It underwent manager changes a few years ago, the performance started to suffer, and there seemed to be some uncertainty. So I sold it. It later improved and recovered. The fund is 55% securitized. When I was thinking about getting back into the fund, I saw that SYFFX, a securitized fund, was outperforming RCTIX. SYFFX outperforms RCTIX at every trailing period I look at. So if I when considering RCTIX, which has more than 50% exposure to the securitized sector (a sector I was underexposed to), I thought that I might as well go with a dedicated securitized fund that has performed better.
Several names mentioned are not really multisector bond funds. Some are core-plus, ST-HY, global HY, nontraditional bond funds. So, keep this in mind when comparing Drawdowns, SD, Sharpe Ratios.
Multisector category includes sovereign bonds, corporates, HY and EMs in a single package. Some follow allocation ranges rigidly (FADMX), some act like go anywhere funds, so may look quite different at times (PONAX / PIMIX).
IMO, a combination of mostly core-plus bond fund and some multisector bond fund cover lot of bond territory.
"IMO, a combination of mostly core-plus bond fund and some multisector bond fund cover lot of bond territory."
I agree. But I'm considering possibly replacing my core-plus bond fund (DOXIX) with a dollar-hedged global bond fund (PGBIX) sometime in the future. https://testfol.io/?s=4XrGJnvG9lB
Just be aware with securitized (MBS) funds.....SYFFX lost -31% in 1Q 2020, as many of these funds were crushed at the time. That's why I don't hold more HOSIX.
Just be aware with securitized (MBS) funds.....SYFFX lost -31% in 1Q 2020, as many of these funds were crushed at the time. That's why I don't hold more HOSIX.
It's not that history will repeat, but it can.
Good observation. I normally don’t look further than 5 years (and place more emphasis on 3 year returns), and don’t look at individual quarters that far back. so I probably would have missed that. That is also something to consider.
Comments
BINC is in iShares/BlackRock universe and there are also similar cousins.
Vanguard has VGMS and cousin VMSIX / VMSAX.
Fido has rather tame FADMX.
It may be worthwhile to consider the following three multisector bond funds.
River Canyon Total Return Bond Fund - Institutional (RCTIX)
Intrepid Income Fund - Institutional (ICMUX)
CrossingBridge Low Duration High Income Fund - Institutional (CBLDX)
I've previously owned RCTIX.
-CBLDX (Crossingbridge)
-APDPX (Global unconstrained)
-HOSIX
-NRDCX (Crossingbridge - Nordic fund) is an interesting add
-DHEIX - short-term HY.
This mix should maintain a very low SD, if recent history is any indicator.
I was looking at Vanguard Multi-Sector Income Bond VMSAX. It looks nice a nice fund, but it had a fairly big drawdown in April (about the same as PIMIX).
I sold RCTIX due to an abrupt manager departure.
https://www.mutualfundobserver.com/discuss/discussion/comment/147655/#Comment_147655
Multisector category includes sovereign bonds, corporates, HY and EMs in a single package. Some follow allocation ranges rigidly (FADMX), some act like go anywhere funds, so may look quite different at times (PONAX / PIMIX).
IMO, a combination of mostly core-plus bond fund and some multisector bond fund cover lot of bond territory.
I agree.
But I'm considering possibly replacing my core-plus bond fund (DOXIX)
with a dollar-hedged global bond fund (PGBIX) sometime in the future.
https://testfol.io/?s=4XrGJnvG9lB
It's not that history will repeat, but it can.