Reply to
@ducrow:
Happy to help! Some thoughts
1. New fund. A hedge fund may not always translate to a good mutual fund. See NARFX (which was sold and turned into another fund.) Not comparing management of NARFX to this fund or anything, but I suppose it's a belief that a hedge fund strategy does not always carry over to the mutual fund world. However, the Whitebox fund is doing well so far.
2. FPA Crescent (FPACX) may have a couple of issues (structural - it could probably close), but I think it's still an excellent fund with a great manager in Romick (whose views I continue to agree with a great deal.) Personally, I don't know if I'd replace it or if this is an apples-to-apples replacement. The Whitebox fund is a new fund, but I think this is going to be a unique/unusual offering in that part of the stock holdings may be broad, but there may be a sizable portion in contrarian ideas/plays/themes - a further discussion by the manager regarding his nat gas theme is available in this Barrons article (
http://www.forbes.com/sites/steveschaefer/2012/05/31/why-it-might-finally-be-time-for-natural-gas-to-make-a-comeback/)
Also note, from the Whitebox quarterly report: "Our fund is not currently “market neutral.” We have a strong “long-bias”. At
other times we may have a strong short bias. Our returns will reflect at least a
portion of day to day, normal market volatility. Our goal is to outperform not by
delivering smooth returns all the time. Our goal is to outperform by doing two
things. (1) Avoiding catastrophic
capital losses that can derail an investment
program for years, or forever. (2) Being invested in areas of exceptional
opportunity wherever in securities markets those opportunities arise."
So, the fund definitely has the flexibility to dial up and down risk, to the point where it can have a "strong short bias."
3. Amusing name. Whitebox is a play on the opaque "black box" strategies that hedge funds often have. Their big thing is being transparent with shareholders in communications and otherwise.
4. Again, while the hedge fund may be highly regarded, new mutual fund. However, there is a lot available online about the manager. Their "Whitebox Selected Research" is enjoyable reading, both from the articles from others and the articles from Whitebox. Redleaf wrote a book, "Panic", about the financial crisis, which does not appear to be available new anymore from amazon, but is available used, and got good reviews.
5. One other interesting note: the co-manager of the fund is ROB VOGEL
Rob Vogel joined Whitebox Advisors, LLC in 1999 as a convertible bond trader. From 1995 – 1999, Rob was a convertible bond trader for EBF & Associates of Minneapolis. From 1991 – 1995, Rob was an actuary and ran statistical models to estimate insurance reserves. Rob holds an MBA from the University of Minnesota and a BS in Applied Mathematics and Statistics from the University of Florida.
If you look under the Whitebox Selected Research, there is an article from Hedge Fund Review, awarding "Whitebox Concentrated Convertible Arbitrage" the "Best Non-Directional Hedge Fund Over 10 Years"
So, beyond what's available on Redleaf, this gives you some idea about the background of another manager on the fund:
http://www.whiteboxselectedresearch.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/08/HFR-Article-on-Convertible.pdfUnder that article about the convertible arb hedge fund: "The fund’s investments are
guided by Whitebox’s distinctive
market philosophy. One of the core
themes is to “be more invested at the
bottom than the top”. This reflects
Whitebox’s view that contrary to
conventional investment theories,
markets actually tend to be more
risky when they are less volatile."
“When markets are less volatile,
prices are generally higher, which
probably makes them riskier,” Vogel
explains. “We aim to be less exposed
when markets are tranquil so that,
if the cycle turns and prices get
cheaper, we can add to positions.”
As for the last manager, I think this is awfully interesting: " Prior to joining Whitebox Advisors, LLC in 2002, Jason spent two years working with Nobel Laureate Myron Scholes at Oak Hill Platinum Partners where he developed models for long/short equity strategies. "
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Myron_Scholes____
Lastly, I don't really want to tell David what to do, but I do agree this is really a fund that would be perfect for a profile. It only has 9.5M under management, but a pretty highly regarded management team.