It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!
Today thousands of health workers at the CDC and FDA lost their jobs—effective immediately. Some found out when they tried to badge in, only to be denied entry. Twelve senior leaders were offered reassignment—with just 24 hours to decide. In other words, fired without being formally fired.
It’s cruel and unnecessary—and that’s the point. It’s also dangerous.
Health divisions are gone, and programs are gutted
• HIV prevention? Gone.
• Asthma and air quality team? Gone.
• Environmental hazard response? Gone.
• Gun violence prevention? Gutted.
• Communications? Gutted.
• Worker safety? Gone.
• Reproductive health? Gone.
• Birth defects? Gone.
• Disability health? Gone.
• TB prevention? Gone.
• Blood disorder programs? Gone.
• National survey on drug use and mental health? Gone.
• Lead poisoning prevention? Gone.
• Water safety? Gone.
• Tobacco control division? Gone.
And that’s just CDC. FDA has a list. Same with NIH.
There’s no question that health institutions can be run more efficiently. I spent the last three years inside the CDC pushing for change—fighting for innovation, better systems, and clearer communication. I agree with some cuts and reorganization. Reimagining public health is essential. But tearing it down with no plan to rebuild isn’t transformation. It’s sabotage.
The ultimate justification for these cuts is cost savings. But these cuts do not make financial sense. Federal workers make up less than 1% of the HHS budget. And, public health programs are all about prevention—which is not only good for our health but can be much cheaper than treating disease. For every $1 spent on flu vaccines for the elderly, $60 are saved. For every $1 spent in NIH funding, $4.25 is added to the local economies. Cutting these programs may save a dollar today, but when people start to get sick because of eliminated programs, we’ll pay many times more in health care costs down the road, much out of the government’s pocket for Medicare. We’re borrowing from our future selves with far too high an interest rate: in dollars, in health, and in lives. In the meantime, the U.S. is giving a big gift to huge corporations that will either step in and privatize or take advantage of this moment, like Big Tobacco.
What is becoming clear
Federal systems are being hollowed out and reduced to a shell. At CDC, it’s as if only some of infectious disease matters, and the rest of public health is expendable. This is hard to reconcile, given RFK's previous messaging about the importance of chronic disease. It also ignores that chronic and infectious diseases are deeply linked. Zika and pregnancy. Obesity and Covid. Health doesn’t exist in silos.
Furthermore, these cuts also affect service to the most vulnerable: people living with sickle cell disease or disabilities, communities with suboptimal access to resources like oral health, and those exposed to environmental hazards. With these cuts, for example, a health response won’t be ready for a train derailment toxic spill, like in Ohio a few years ago.
Viruses don’t stop when the government does. Neither do bacteria, natural disasters, gun violence, rising rates of depression, suicide, or health emergencies. Public health isn’t something you can pause and expect to pick back up later. It’s built on decades of momentum and lessons learned.
I think destruction will continue to come. More jobs cut. More reorganizing. And more people will leave because the mission doesn’t align with their value system.
So tonight, I’m still trying to understand: How does this make America healthier? Because from where I sit, this isn’t about health at all. It’s about dismantling the very systems designed to protect it. This will eventually course correct, but in the meantime, it’s doing a whole lot of damage for little short-term gain.
© 2015 Mutual Fund Observer. All rights reserved.
© 2015 Mutual Fund Observer. All rights reserved. Powered by Vanilla
Comments
Rinse and repeat. Way to go, MAGA! Way to go.
the Trump administration's cuts with Kathleen Sebelius, the HHS secretary during the Obama administration."
https://www.pbs.org/newshour/show/important-hhs-services-will-grind-to-a-halt-with-cuts-former-secretary-sebelius-says