Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!

In this Discussion

  • msf March 2016
Here's a statement of the obvious: The opinions expressed here are those of the participants, not those of the Mutual Fund Observer. We cannot vouch for the accuracy or appropriateness of any of it, though we do encourage civility and good humor.

    Support MFO

  • Donate through PayPal

Fidelity To Elimnate Class B Shares On 102 Advisor Funds

FYI: Class B Shares:: (Source Investopedia)
These shares are classified by their back-end or contingent deferred sales charge. These shares are typically good for investors with little investment cash and a long investment horizon.

Pros
No Front-End Fees - Your entire initial investment contribution earns interest income.
Deferred Sales Charges - The longer you hold the shares, the lower your deferred sales charge.
Conversion to Class A - Class B shares automatically convert to Class A shares after a certain period of time. This is beneficial because Class A shares have a lower yearly expense ratio than Class B shares (see below).

Cons
Long Time Horizon Required - If you withdraw funds within a certain period of time (typically five to eight years) you are a charged a back-end or deferred sales charge.
No Breakpoints - Class B shares do not provide breakpoints on the deferred sales charge, so regardless of how much you invest, there is no discount on these charges.
Higher Expense Ratios - Class B shares charge higher expense ratios than both Class A and C shares, until shares are eligible to be converted to Class A.
Regards,
Ted
http://www.mfwire.com/common/artprint2007.asp?storyID=53556&wireid=2

Comments

  • Class B shares seem like one of the most misunderstood, maligned vehicles around. (I'm not defending load funds here, just looking at reputation vs. numbers.)
    Ted said:

    FYI: Class B Shares:: (Source Investopedia)
    [...]
    Cons
    Long Time Horizon Required - If you withdraw funds within a certain period of time (typically five to eight years) you are a charged a back-end or deferred sales charge.
    No Breakpoints - Class B shares do not provide breakpoints on the deferred sales charge, so regardless of how much you invest, there is no discount on these charges.
    Higher Expense Ratios - Class B shares charge higher expense ratios than both Class A and C shares, until shares are eligible to be converted to Class A.

    One of those cons is accurate, and IMHO the only objective negative to B shares (relative to A shares) - they don't give you a break in your commissions (loads) for larger portfolios.

    There is one other downside but that has to do with psychology (marketing), not numbers. B shares are/were sold as "putting 100% of your money to work", implying that they were superior to A shares where you pay a load up front. Because of the higher 12b-1 fee (embedded load), B shares put some of that money to work for your broker, not for you. The structure made for an easier sale, but no clear advantage (or disadvantage) relative to A shares.

    That gets us to the first dubious con: long time horizon required because of the deferred sales charge. A shares charge the full load up front. B shares amortize that load over several years, by charging an extra 0.75% (typical) in 12b-1 fees annually. Once the load has been amortized, they convert to A shares. If you sell early, then you have to pay that part of the load that hasn't yet been amortized - that's the deferred sales charge. The bottom line is that you wind up taking the same hit on return (due to the load) as with A shares whether you hold B shares for a long time (in which case you've paid the whole load over time), or whether you sell them quickly (in which case you've paid most of the load in a lump sum - just like A shares).

    The other con listed - that B shares tend to have higher expenses than C shares - is just wrong. B and C shares typically have the same ERs, give or take a few basis points. That's because they both generally add a 1.00% 12b-1 fee and have the same management fees. The rest ("other expenses") is noise.

    A good example is Fidelity Advisor Freedom® 2005 Fund. Here's M*'s purchase page, that shows the ERs for each share class. It is 1.00% for B shares and for C shares. This fund is great for showing the pure difference between share class expenses. As a Fidelity fund of funds it charges 0.00% for the fund; any extra fee is due strictly to the share class sales structure (i.e. load - front, back, level or combo).

    The summary prospectus shows the ERs as 1.56%, because that includes the cost of the underlying funds (0.56%).

    To reiterate, I am not defending load funds. I am saying that B shares are usually misrepresented (both on the positive side as I noted above, and on the negative side as by Investopedia).
Sign In or Register to comment.