Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!

Here's a statement of the obvious: The opinions expressed here are those of the participants, not those of the Mutual Fund Observer. We cannot vouch for the accuracy or appropriateness of any of it, though we do encourage civility and good humor.
  • TIAA brokerage accounts
    You Invest by Chase had a variety of quirks as well. The main attraction to me was 3100 ntf funds that could be sold anytime without incurring early redemption transaction fees. There was no list of funds available before I invested, but when Chase confirmed I could buy PRWBX DODIX and SHSAX ntf, I opened an account. Unfortunately, my brokerage account was locked twice, and I initiated a full account transfer to Fidelity.
  • Unexpected Fund Distributions-Avoided Donut Infamy
    SHSAX and BALPX apparently made a mid year distribution in the range of 2-3% today. Fidelity revealed this info minutes ago after I started this discussion, saving me from looking even more foolish !
  • Revisiting Defensive Funds
    @Baseball_Fan.... To be nice, I'll mention that Hussman's Total Return fund (HSTRX) only had 2 down calendar years out of 18, with a +5% average return over the life of the fund.
    Not sure which of his funds you dabble with. His newer Allocation fund (HSAFX) has done kinda ok so far.
    But yeah, he missed the Fed boat completely, and he never corrected/adjusted appropriately. Stubborn.
  • How many different mutual funds do you own?
    Taxable 1 - 3 mutual funds, 1 ETF
    Taxable 2 - 1 individual stock
    401(k) - 2 mutual funds (one fund will be replaced by a CIT "clone" on 07/01), 1 CIT
    Roth IRA - 3 mutual funds (one fund is also owned in Taxable 1 account)
    HSA - 1 mutual fund
  • Recommendations for new fund house?
    Lots of semi-random comments:
    Hank's The [Fidelity] 30-day limitation for in-house funds is perfectly reasonable - roughly what TRP insists on.
    This reflects each fund house's excessive trading policy - something similar to but different from short term redemption fees. A key difference is that redemption fees are "just" money. Excessive trading rules can lock you out of trading. No Fidelity fund has a short term fee, and I believe the same is true for TRP funds.
    TRP's policy can be found in each fund's statutory prospectus. It bars you from buying shares in a fund account if you sold shares from that account within 30 days. Notice the time constraint is on sell followed by purchase. All you need are two transactions (sell followed by buy) to trigger a restriction. Vanguard has a similar policy.
    Fidelity's policy is more complex. It defines a short term round trip as a buy followed by a sell within 30 days. The policy begins to take effect only if you execute two round trips within 90 days of each other.
    This seems somewhat less restrictive: you're allowed to buy/sell/buy in any time frame with no consequences. It's only the second short term (30 day) sell that triggers a freeze. But if triggered, it lasts longer than at TRP; at Fidelity the bar against purchases lasts 85 days and you're placed on a watch list.
    Fidelity's Excessive Trading Policy and 2020 Update
    In Mona's boglehead's link, the OP writes: HSA w/ company which im maxing out and investing it in Vanguard Real Estate Fund.
    There's no response to this part of the post, but Fidelity offers the cheapest, broadest HSA around (it's a regular brokerage account). Many employer HSAs have fees or restrictions attached. What one can do is contribute to the employer's HSA (to get added employee tax benefits and match) and then transfer the money to an external (Fidelity) HSA. One can even buy a share class of Vanguard Real Estate Fund VNQ with no commission in a Fidelity HSA.
    I agree with much of what sma3 wrote (also having had accounts at Vanguard, Fidelity, and Schwab for years). Though here are some items that reasonable people can view differently:
    Vanguard is clunky
    Likely true for many operations; I find it easy to use for the only thing I care about there: buying and selling mutual funds
    Fidelity has ... an easy website
    Yes, but the more they change it to look like their small screen ap, the worse it gets. Fidelity recently changed its bill payment interface so now I have to go through multiple screens to accomplish what used to be easier. And I can no longer give it a list of payees to display by default; it always starts with every one I've left in the system.
    Vanguard is ... putting up more and more restrictions on nonV funds
    It doesn't let you buy or sell leveraged/inverse ETFs. OTOH, to buy aggressive funds like PQTAX, Fidelity requires you to sign an agreement and set your account investment objective to most aggressive, while Vanguard just puts up a dialog box informing you that you should be aware of the risks.
    A few years ago, Schwab stopped selling load funds (unless they were sold load-waived). I believe Vanguard has a similar policy. Fidelity still sells funds with loads. The way this may play out is that, e.g. for NMFAX, Fidelity will sell the A shares with a load, Schwab will have arranged for them to be sold NTF, and Vanguard won't sell them.
  • Recommendations for new fund house?
    As with Vanguard, the question may be moot. AFAIK, one can't open a fund position directly in either family.
    Sample prospectus boilerplate:
    If you do not currently have a Fidelity ® brokerage account or a Fidelity ® mutual fund account and would like to invest in a fund, you may need to complete an application. For more information about a Fidelity ® brokerage account or a Fidelity ® mutual fund account, please visit Fidelity's web site at www.fidelity.com, call 1-800-FIDELITY, or visit a Fidelity Investor Center (call 1-800-544-9797 for the center nearest you).
    But all one finds on Fidelity.com is this list of "accounts for investing":
    Brokerage Accounts, Cash Management Accounts, HSA Accounts, and 529 College Savings Plans.
    No mutual fund accounts.
    https://www.fidelity.com/customer-service/investing
    Under Forms, if one checks "open an account" one sees a plethora of account forms, but the only two forms presented to open a vanilla, individual taxable account are a CMA (brokerage) application and a "Non-Retirement Brokerage Account for Individuals, Joint" application.
    https://www.fidelity.com/customer-service/forms-applications/all-forms
    Decades ago, Fidelity nudged all investors off of their mutual fund platform onto their brokerage platform. (Who remembers T-account numbers?) Vanguard is in the middle of that process now.
  • Q&A - Bucket Strategies in Retirement
    @msf said,
    You don't want more money in the HSAs than you can withdraw tax-free (not enough medical expenses). Keep the faster growing assets in the genuine Roth IRAs.
    An HSA can be inherited by a spouse...maybe the term is rolled into a spouse's HSA when a spouse is the benficiary of an HSA. So maybe having a little extra for that purpose makes sense. Otherwise, an HSA used for non-medical purposes (after age 65), is treated much like a deferred IRA with no RMDs.
  • Q&A - Bucket Strategies in Retirement
    I found this very interesting and worth sharing.
    ...
    https://theretirementmanifesto.com/your-bucket-strategy-questions-answered/
    A good, common sense piece with a bit of substance to it. A few items there worth highlighting:
    - Asset allocation. Rather than work with fixed percentages, the allocation is done by time: so many years in cash, so many years in bonds, and the remainder in equities. In his case, he came up with 63% (not 60%) in equities. He's actually got a pretty conservative cash (3 year) / bond (8 year) allocation. The cash/bond allocation lets you invest the remainder (however much that is) in equities without worrying about sequence of return risk, volatility "risk", etc.
    - Annuities. He avoids the question of what bucket this income stream (or pensions, or SS) falls into. If one were targeting a particular asset allocation, then this question would matter. But because he's basing cash and bond allocations on how much extra income he needs, this question never arises.
    He touches on annuity strategies, which seems beyond the scope of bucket strategies. But since he went there, it's worth reiterating that for many people, using retirement assets to defer SS until age 70 is the optimal strategy.
    In a new paper summarized here, 401(k) assets would be used to automatically provide an income stream until age 70. A temporary life annuity can provide the same income stream while enhancing value with mortality credits. (The downside is that if you die before age 70, you don't get the full value of the temporary annuity.)
    https://www.kitces.com/blog/understanding-the-role-of-mortality-credits-why-immediate-annuities-beat-bond-ladders-for-retirement-income/
    - HSAs. He keeps his in cash, presumably to spend as expenses are incurred. For investing, he recommends bucket 3 (equities). My take is different - I suggest bucket 2.
    HSAs are like Roth IRAs - withdrawals are tax-free - so long as one can pair them with past medical expenses. I would put my slower growing Roth-ish assets into HSAs to limit the risk that the HSAs grow too fast. You don't want more money in the HSAs than you can withdraw tax-free (not enough medical expenses). Keep the faster growing assets in the genuine Roth IRAs.
  • Health Sector Funds: FSPHX vs FSMEX and others
    I have a small position in FSPHX and have had it for a while. I've been taking a closer look at FSMEX and I can't come up with a reason to keep FSPHX over FSMEX. Using premium... PRHSX and SHSAX along with a newcomer I've been watching ETIHX comes up. But it just seems FSMEX is far and away the consistent performer - looking at APR vs. Peer, Ulcer, Martin and DD. It has been outperforming my current FSPHX which had a tough 2020 in the vs. peer category. That said, it's beaten the S&P 500 consistently since it's inception. But so has FSMEX.
    Just wondering if anyone has an opinion.
  • Portfolio Fun...
    TGGFX PFOAX GSGIX Diversified in case 1 blows up! SHSAX more sedate health care fund with low minimums at Schwab.
  • Long M* Interview with PRWCX's David Giroux
    I tried to purchase ITCSX at Saturna, which uses Pershing Fund marketplace AFAIK. Got the following message: "The fund you have selected is not available to be purchased by residents of your state or country. Please contact Saturna for further assistance". Already own PRWCX in this HSA account, but Pershing was mentioned as one of the platforms that offers it, so I thought I'd check it out.
  • Time for Hussman? High Grade Rubies? Artisan Focus ARTTX
    Ya, I guess with Dr Hussman the old saying, I'd rather be rich than right comes to mind. Have to state, if you read his commentary, directionally it makes a lot of rational sense...kind of the opposite of GME, Gamestop, ARK moonshot investing, etc.
    Candidly, I always found it interesting that those who did NOT sell in 08'-09' and just held were considered "smart investors". As I recall at the time, the market could have easily lost another 50% at the lows, no one knew that the Bernake and the Fed were going to implement QE. Back then saw many "wise" investors come back to work after they retired as they "buy and hold'ed" and got sawed in half, 401k to 201k, home values plummeted, dangerous, frightening times...remember talk one weekend of the entire financial system locking up...thank goodness Paulsen saved us (sarc or did he really?)
    I'm more interested in HSAFX than the older growth fund HSGFX...the former being more of an allocation fund. That being said I can't seem to purchase HSAFX thru Schwab. I think it's going to take combo of technical, trend and valuation investing skill sets and sure, pure luck to make sustainable money in the markets this year.
    Best,
    Baseball Fan
  • Time for Hussman? High Grade Rubies? Artisan Focus ARTTX
    Perhaps the clocks Hussman uses are engineered such that they finally work well again (they did for a while in the past). It's worth considering. Will look into HSAFX some more. Thanks for bringing it up......
  • Time for Hussman? High Grade Rubies? Artisan Focus ARTTX
    Good Morning Class,
    I'm thinking when we look back at the "markets" (casino?) at the end of the year, we're going to realize that in late January we were facing a very binary outcome...either the majority of us get the jab in the arm (key could be JNJ vaccine (?), there is a antidote by Merck or with the new admin, taxes go up, regulations go up, socialistic spending ramps up and markets (casino?) craters....look at the nonsense with GME Gamestop...you wanna put your life savings into this sheet show?
    so...
    1) Is it time for Hussman, HSGFX or HSAFX...go ahead and call me crazee but don't call me Shirley but I'm going to step into the Huss with a noticeable investment today.
    2) Is it time for high grade rubies? I recall a passionate discussion during the "Financial Crisis" (housing bubble scam) with my CFO and others by the water cooler how you could shove a million dollars of high grade rubies in your sock and no one would know they were there...shared stories from my Grandma how her wealth was confiscated by the democratic socialists under Tito...she was lucky to escape with her life as they usually popped the wealthy
    I recall The Gundlach stated he "likes real assets that he can put in the trunk of his car" (paraphrasing)
    3) On the other half, I'm thinking the markets might be up 30-40% if the vaccines take effect, we don't have the nutty tweeties anymore and things calm down, economy and jobs pick up etc..so slowly adding to ARTTX on down days
    4) I'd rather myself play the "bro-investor" approach by buying stocks like Penn Gaming than Bitcoin...
    Like I said, binary, place your bets? Of course, posting for entertainment purposes only, I have no idea what will happen this year, etc.
    Best and good health to all,
    Baseball Fan
  • Fund Spy: Top HSA Providers of 2020
    The correct link:
    https://www.financial-planning.com/news/moving-money-from-ira-to-hsa-the-only-time-it-makes-sense
    As the article says, unless you're cash strapped and have medical costs exceeding what's in your HSA (plus taxable cash) is this worth considering.
  • Fund Spy: Top HSA Providers of 2020
    Funding your HSA with your IRA :
    A little-known rule buried deep on the IRS website presents a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity for clients with a health savings account — the ability to make a contribution directly from an IRA.
    Although this one-time offer isn’t worth the effort for most clients, who’d be better off continuing to fund both accounts and collect dual tax breaks for doing so, there are a handful of situations where cash-strapped clients with high medical costs could really benefit from making the move and tapping tax- and penalty-free funds.
    moving-money-from-ira-to-hsa-the-only-time-it-makes-sense
  • Fund Spy: Top HSA Providers of 2020
    Fidelity continues to stand out as the best HSA for investing
    More Here
  • Perpetual Buy/Sell/Why Thread
    On Friday, finally took profits on 7 year holding PRHSX Performance has lagged and Sharpe Ratio slumped since superstar Kris Jenner left. Will slowly redeploy assets into SHSAX FSPHX and XLV over following weeks.
  • Perpetual Buy/Sell/Why Thread

    My sentiments exactly. By year-end I will have DCA'd well over the amount needed to convert the shares to lower-priced PRILX.
    The only hiccup I had with them was that they held onto scandal-plagued WFC for too long as its largest holding - I sold out on principle back then, and bought it back for my Roth IRA the day I learned they closed the position.
    I really like the Parnassus Core Equity Fund for the following reasons:
    • Long-tenured managers (start dates of 2001 and 2012) who have over $1M invested in the fund
    • Good downside protection
    • Moderate turnover for an actively managed fund
    • Portfolio is not overly diworsified (39 holdings as of 06/30/20)
    • Good long-term performance
    My HSA is invested entirely in PRILX.
  • Perpetual Buy/Sell/Why Thread
    I really like the Parnassus Core Equity Fund for the following reasons:
    • Long-tenured managers (start dates of 2001 and 2012) who have over $1M invested in the fund
    • Good downside protection
    • Moderate turnover for an actively managed fund
    • Portfolio is not overly diworsified (39 holdings as of 06/30/20)
    • Good long-term performance
    My HSA is invested entirely in PRILX.