It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!
Vanguard index funds are the exception that proves the rule - for a $10K min - not institutional, and not an outrageous amount - Vanguard's Admiral shares generally carry the same expense ratio as their ETF shares. S&P 500 - 0.05%, FTSE All World ex-US - 0.18%, Extended Market - 0.14%, Total Bond - 0.10%, Total Stock - 0.06%, etc.. And because these are just two different share classes of the same funds, the reduction in costs that Jaffe is lauding on Vanguard's ETFs will show up in the Admiral shares also.With the exception of a few cost leaders — mostly institutional funds requiring big holdings — ETFs are dramatically cheaper than traditional funds covering the same indexes.
This means that Admiral shares are only somewhat less expensive to buy and sell - you get them at NAV, rather than getting penalized by a bid/ask spread whenever you buy or sell, as you would with an ETF.The one advantage traditional funds have is that an investor can dollar-cost average into the fund without paying repeated commissions, but no-transaction-fee ETFs offset this advantage.
Obviously not true for two shares classes (Admiral, ETF) of the same portfolio. Dividends and capital gains get distributed pro-rata to all shares, whether they are ETF class or other class.Index ETFs have a slight edge in tax efficiency over traditional index funds too.
10/1/12-
Change AF = American Funds
% of Since AC = American Century
PF 9/24/12 S: = Schwab Account
ANCFX 7.1% -0.36% AF Fundamental Investors
SMCWX 3.8% 0% AF Smallcap World Fund
CWGIX 2.2% -0.14% AF Capital World Growth & Income
ANEFX 6.9% -0.31% AF New Economy Fund
GABAX 2.5% -0.76% S: Gabelli Asset
MAPIX 0.9% -0.43% S: Matthews Asia Dividend
GASFX 0.9% -0.27% S: FBR Fund Advisors
MFLDX 2.1% -1.52% S: Marketfield
ABALX 16.2% -0.29% AF American Balanced Fund
GBLAX 0.1% -0.46% AF Global Balanced
TWSMX 9.1% 0.01% AC Strategic Allocation (Moderate)
ABNDX 9.5% 0.35% AF Bond Fund of America
AIBAX 7.5% 0.07% AF Intermediate Bond Fund
CWBFX 0.6% 0.23% AF Capital World Bond Fund
AHITX 10.6% -0.36% AF High Income Trust
ABHIX 4.7% -0.17% AC High Yield Bond Fund
BGNMX 1.1% 0.24% AC GNMA Bond Fund
ADFIX 2.8% 0.45% AC Diversified Bond Fund
ACITX 8.4% 0.37% AC Inflation Adjusted Bond Fund
RPHYX 0.8% 0.05% S: Riverpark Short Term HY
PONDX 2.2% 0.6% S: PIMCO Income Fund (D)
Total Weekly Portfolio Change: 0.1%
© 2015 Mutual Fund Observer. All rights reserved.
© 2015 Mutual Fund Observer. All rights reserved. Powered by Vanilla