Giving some more thought to risk and needs ...
Derivatives - in a sense, insurance policies are derivatives - they value depends on the state of the asset being insured. Insure a car against vandalism and the value of the car plus policy is constant (less deductible if the car is vandalized). The policy never adds risk. Just the cost of the insurance.
Similarly, some derivatives act as pure insurance (reducing risk) and do not affect volatility. A put option on a security that has a strike price below the security price insures against the price declining below the strike price. Just as you pay a premium for your auto insurance, you pay a premium for your security's "price insurance".
On the other hand, derivatives can also be used aggressively. I've been looking at CSHI - a 1-3 month Treasury ETF that uses an option kicker to enhance performance. It uses a
short put spread on something totally unrelated - the S&P
500 index (SPX). It's a pure gamble - if the "market" (S&P
500) goes up or remains flat, the puts expire worthless and the fund pockets the difference between the premiums of the two puts (one sold, one purchased). If the market goes down, then it could lose some money, but that loss is limited by the put it owns.
Seeking Alpha
seems to like this ETF. At a superficial (numbers) level it looks like a tamer APDPX, returning half as much annually in exchange for 1/
5 the volatility (std dev). Here's the
Portfolio Visualizer comparison.
A few observations:
Numbers don't tell the whole story; it helps to dig below the surface as
@dtconroe has been doing.
Month-to-month figures can miss a lot (e.g. PV reports 0.0% max drawdown for CSHI). Right after the Seeking Alpha piece was written (March 202
5), we had the intra-month April Liberation Day tariffs.
APDPX -1.73% (April 2 - April 9)
CSHI -1.
52% (April 2 - April 8)
CBLDX -0.93% (April 2 - April 11)
BBBIX -0.4
5% (April 3 - April 11)
RPHIX -0.31% (April 3 - April 9)
Derivatives can be 100% safe or extremely risky depending at least as much on how they are used as on market conditions. FPNIX is a fine example of a fund that makes extensive use of derivatives but with an eye to minimizing risk.
Different people have different needs - I looked at CSHI because I'm looking for where to put cash in a taxable account. Holding Treasuries wouldn't help (on taxes) in an IRA.
Another observation on FPNIX - M* reports that the MBSs it invests in charge the underlying borrowers such low rates that they wouldn't refinance even if current mortgage rates drop. This allays some of my concerns about prepayment risk/negative convexity. Issue selection matters.
M* just wrote up
four ultrashort funds including BBBIX. Personally I like what it says about BBBIX being toward the risky end of ultrashort. I'm looking to extend beyond "ultra-safe" funds without taking on the risk of general bond funds (I have other funds for that). As always, YMMV.