Category Archives: Mutual Fund Commentary

Briefly Noted

By TheShadow

Updates

SEC slaps GQG: The US Securities and Exchange Commission levied a $500,000 fine against GQG Partners and Rajiv Jain for violations of whistleblower protection laws and issued a cease-and-desist order against the illegal practices. At base, GQG required (some?) new hires and one former employee to sign agreements which would make it difficult for them to disclose wrongdoing on GQG’s part. “Whether through agreements or otherwise, firms cannot impose barriers to persons providing evidence about possible securities law violations to the SEC, as GQG did,” said Corey Schuster, Co-Chief of the Division of Enforcement’s Asset Management Unit.

As of 27 September 2024, GQG’s website did not reflect any discussion of the action. Reports in other media note that GQG “acknowledged the SEC’s jurisdiction in the case Continue reading →

September 1, 2024

By David Snowball

Dear friends,

Welcome to the September (aka “back to school”) issue of the Mutual Fund Observer. The joyful tumult of which has slightly delayed our launch.

Despair is easy. If you ever want an antidote, drop by Augie at the beginning of September. As many of you know, in my day job, I am a professor of communication studies and director of the Austin E Knowlton Honors Program at Augustana College. I am also an advisor to first-year students. I’ve spent much of the last week meeting with and learning about my new charges. I am amazed by them, defying as they do all of the hysterical media headlines about Continue reading →

The Young Investor’s Indolent Portfolio

By David Snowball

An indolent portfolio is an investor’s best friend. It is a portfolio designed to be ignored for a year at a time. Why is that a good idea? Two reasons, really. First, almost everything you do with your portfolio will be a mistake. Morningstar’s long-running series of “Mind the Gap” studies looks at the difference between investor’s actual returns and the returns of the funds in which they are invested.

Those annuals routinely show that investors’ returns Continue reading →

Happy 94th, Warren! In celebration, I did not nothing

By Devesh Shah

The bouncing baby Warren Edward Buffett entered the world on 30 August 1930, the only son of Laila and Howard Buffett. In celebration of this 94th birthday, I looked seriously at my portfolio … and did absolutely nothing.

That was hard, but baby Warren would have wanted it that way.

Introduction

In this article, I look back at the market lows in October 2022. Continue reading →

MFO Premium Introduces ETF Benchmarks

By Charles Boccadoro

Our colleague Devesh Shah encouraged the incorporation of ETF Benchmarks into MFO Premium. Traditional benchmarks cannot be purchased. Similarly, category averages, which are the basis for much of the ratings on MFO Premium, also cannot be purchased. Establishing an ETF “benchmark,” Devesh argues, makes for a more relevant and practical comparison.

Furthermore, the Continue reading →

Launch Alert: Research Affiliates Deletions ETF (NIXT)

By David Snowball

On September 10, 2024, Research Affiliates will launch its first ETF. Research Affiliates was founded in 2002 by Rob Arnott to provide professional and institutional investors with innovative research and product development. Mr. Arnott is iconic, having published 150 or so research articles that received both attention and rewards. His most extensive work is The Fundamental Index: A Better Way to Invest (2008). Most traditional indexes are capitalization-weighted, so they lock in a large/growth/momentum bias. Arnott notes that the bias may Continue reading →

Briefly Noted

By TheShadow

Updates

Tortoise Capital Advisors is merging three closed-end funds, with combined assets of over $300 million, into a single actively managed ETF. The current funds are Tortoise Power and Energy Infrastructure Fund (TPZ), Tortoise Pipeline & Energy Fund (TTP), and Tortoise Energy Independence Fund (NDP). They will be supplanted by the Tortoise Power and Energy Infrastructure ETF which will adopt TPZ’s strategy for its own. As a warning Continue reading →

August 1, 2024

By David Snowball

“It’s a sure sign of summer if the chair gets up when you do.” Walter Winchell

Walter who?  O tempora! O mores!  

At the height of his popularity, in the late 1930s, 50 million people—two-thirds of American adults—read Winchell’s syndicated column and listened to his 15-minute Sunday-night radio broadcast. He positioned himself as a champion of “Mr. and Mrs. America,” and was the most powerful – or, at least, most Continue reading →

Small Cap Funds: Better than the best

By David Snowball

In July 2024, Morningstar.com published a promising but ultimately disappointing article entitled “The Best Small-Cap Funds” (7/18/2024). “Content development editor” Tori Brovet has been publishing a series of “The Best” articles (Energy Stocks, Value Funds, Bond ETFs). The article promises there are

They aren’t.

You can do Continue reading →

Launch Alert: Otter Creek Focus Strategy ETF

By David Snowball

On May 17, 2024, Otter Creek Advisors launched the Otter Creek Focus Strategy ETF (OCFS). In doing so, they are providing an existing separately managed account strategy which launched on May 29, 2020, as an ETF. Otter Creek was founded in 1991 to manage a long/short hedge fund and, in 2013, launched a long/short mutual fund. That four-star fund Continue reading →

The Wisdom of the Elders

By Charles Lynn Bolin

I celebrated my 69th birthday last month and will just be reaching my prime next year. I volunteer at Habitat For Humanity two days per week building homes for those that might not otherwise be able to afford them. I have been greatly influenced by the wisdom of the now elders in finance. My friend Dave Hogle and I used to take a three-hour drive to the nearest Costco and discuss Continue reading →

Launch Alert: WPG Partners Select Hedged Fund

By David Snowball

I love a good mystery. WPG Partners Select Hedged is one. It is live, tracked by Morningstar, and available through Schwab, but appears on neither the Boston Partners nor WPG websites. Here’s what to know.

On May 31, 2024, Boston Partners launched WPG Partners Select Hedged, a long/short small-cap fund from its WPG Partners subsidiary. Boston Partners manages Continue reading →

Summer thoughts

By Devesh Shah

“Rest is not idleness, and to lie sometimes on the grass under trees on a summer’s day, listening to the murmur of the water, or watching the clouds float across the sky, is by no means a waste of time.” John Lubbock, The Use Of Life (1896)

I’ve let my brain disconnect from the urgent events of the day (month, season, year …) a bit, and gave it rein to go where Continue reading →

Briefly Noted

By TheShadow

Updates

As of July 19, 2024, the Amplify High Income ETF went from passively tracking an index of the top 45 US closed-end funds to tracking the top 60.

Briefly Noted . . .

The US Securities and Exchange Commission reserves the right to study any proposed fund offering for 70 days before the adviser is permitted to offer the fund for sale to the public. During that time, (a) the SEC might require substantive or editorial changes to the fund’s prospectus and (b) the adviser is permitted to Continue reading →

Launch Alert: T. Rowe Price Intermediate Municipal Income ETF

By David Snowball

On July 10, 2024 – T. Rowe Price launched T. Rowe Price Intermediate Municipal Income ETF (TAXE), an actively managed ETF. Price has 16 other ETFs, including semi-transparent and transparent equity and income funds but this is the first that does not directly mirror an existing fund.

The fund is co-managed by James Lynch and Charlie Hill, who collectively have 53 years of investment experience, and have served Continue reading →

July 1, 2024

By David Snowball

Dear friends,

Welcome to Really, Really Summer … and to the July issue of Mutual Fund Observer.

Summertime is an especially blessed and cursed interval for those of us who teach. On the one hand, we’re mostly freed from the day-to-day obligation to be in the classroom. Some of us write, some travel, and some undertake “such other duties as may from time to time be assigned” by our colleges. On the other hand, we hear the clock ticking. All year long, as we try to face down a stack of 32 variably literate essays at 11 p.m. Sunday night, we think “If I can just make it to summer, I’ll Continue reading →

Morningstar Celebrates 40th Year – MICUS Chicago 2024

By Charles Boccadoro

Morningstar held its annual investment conference [Morningstar Investment Conference US (MICUS) 2024] last week in Chicago, on 26 and 27 June. It employed a new venue and conference schedule: The Navy Pier and a chock-full, two-day agenda. The 292-foot-wide Pier, which opened originally in 1916, and was “built by the city for the people, is the largest in the world, projecting east 3,040 feet into Lake Michigan. It remains the longest public pier in the world today.”

The occasion also Continue reading →

Families you can trust

By David Snowball

Fund families that get it right, over and over

Briefly brilliant performance isn’t all the tough. It requires rather more luck the skill and it can be wildly profitable for the adviser, though deadly for the investors. ARK Innovation ETF is, of course, the current poster child for boom-then-bust. The fund posted triple-digit returns in 2020, saw its assets explode then promptly (and predictably) crashed. Anyone who bought five years ago and has devoutly held on has lost 1% annually and has trailed 99.9% of all similar investors. Those who bought at the peak three years ago have clocked annual Continue reading →

Firms with 100% 10-year Success Rates

By David Snowball

Firms with 100% 5- and 10-Year Success Ratios

No liquidations, no mergers, and 100% of funds posted above-average returns. Of the 68 firms with a 100% 10-year success rate, 41 also have a perfect five-year record.

  Firm Success Ratio 10-Year Firm Success Ratio 5-Year # of funds
Appleseed 100 100 1
Auer 100 100 1
Bretton Fund 100 100 1
Caldwell & Orkin 100 100 1
Cantor Fitzgerald 100 100 2
Changing Parameters 100 100 1
Channel Investment Partners 100 100 1
Clark Fork 100 100 1
Cook & Bynum Capital 100 100 1
Disciplined Growth Investors (DGI) 100 100 1
Dodge & Cox 100 100 6
Equity Investment 100 100 1
First Foundation 100 100 2
Freedom 100 100 1
Hamlin Capital Management 100 100 1
Hillman 100 100 1
Hood River Capital Management 100 100 1
Investment House 100 100 1
Ironclad Funds 100 100 1
Kopernik 100 100 2
Lyrical Partners 100 100 1
MainGate Funds 100 100 1
Matisse Funds 100 100 1
Meehan Focus 100 100 1
Moncapfund 100 100 1
Needham 100 100 3
New Alternatives 100 100 1
OCM 100 100 1
Otter Creek 100 100 1
Payson 100 100 1
Performance Trust Asset Management 100 100 3
Port Street Investments 100 100 1
Private Capital Management 100 100 1
Seafarer 100 100 1
Smead 100 100 2
Sound Shore 100 100 1
Sparrow 100 100 1
Stringer Asset Management 100 100 1
Teberg 100 100 1
Terra Firma Asset Management 100 100 1
Vericimetry 100 100 1

Firms with 100% 10-year success rates, but slippage over the past five years

Inevitably some of the 10-year winners have tailed off more recently. It’s reassuring that only 17 of 68 funds (25%) have tailed off badly, with fewer than half of their 10-year funds still thriving.

  Firm Success Ratio 10-Year Firm Success Ratio 5-Year
Fuller & Thaler 100 83
WCM Investment Management 100 75
Bridge Builder 100 75
Grandeur Peak 100 71
Trillium 100 50
Prospector 100 50
Medalist Partner 100 50
Jensen 100 50
Campbell & Company 100 33
Oakhurst 100 25
Swan Wealth Advisors 100 20
YCG FUNDS 100 0
Reaves 100 0
Polen Capital 100 0
Polaris Capital Management 100 0
MP 63 100 0
MAI 100 0
Long Short 100 0
Lisanti Capital Growth 100 0
JAG Capital Management 100 0
EIP Funds 100 0
Edgewood 100 0
Copley 100 0
Conestoga 100 0
Clifford Capital 100 0
BBW Capital 100 0
Akre 100 0